One of the more predictable outcomes from the ICC meetings over the weekend was the re-election of ICC president Jay Shah. Well, I say re-election, but given that he was unopposed, it's perhaps the wrong word. Why unopposed you might ask? Well the iron grip that the BCCI - cheered on by the ECB and Cricket Australia - has on the power structure of the ICC, who would be brave enough to challenge him?

This was an election in the same way that the Democratic People's Republic of North Korea has elections - democratic in a country name working in much the same way as London in the name of an airport - in that only one name was on the ballot and whilst you could in theory vote no, why take the risk of awkward questions being asked?

ICC president Jay ShahICC president Jay Shah (ICC)

I learnt of this news before opening my e-mail to read the latest newspeak that passes for ICC media releases when I came across a post from the Cricket Association of Nepal reading, "Cricket Association of Nepal (CAN) extends its heartfelt congratulations and best wishes to Mr. Jay Shah on being elected (sic) as President of the International Cricket Council (ICC). We wish him continued success and leadership in taking world cricket to greater heights. May his tenure bring further growth, stronger governance, better structures, and greater opportunities for the development of cricket across all nations."

Now Nepal have made very clear their desire to play Test cricket and are thought to be readying a bid for ICC full membership, so perhaps some degree of sucking up to the boss can be expected. But what about the Tanzania Cricket Association who said "The Tanzania Cricket Association extends its heartfelt congratulations to Mr Jaybhai Shah on his unopposed reappointment for a second term as Chairman of the International Cricket Council (ICC). His continued leadership is an important milestone for the global cricket community, and we look forward to seeing the game continue to grow, evolve and reach new audiences under his guidance."

That's just two, but there are more, and all are fawning in a way that at times resembles someone trapped in a cult.

The question has to be asked though - is Jay Shah actually improving the game for associate members? The evidence isn't strong. The planned expansion of the World Cup to 14 teams has been curtailed to just 12 teams (no matter what the ICC says, the so-called Super Series is just another qualifying stage), the World Cup Qualifier - one of the ICC's oldest tournaments - has been relegated to a qualifier for a qualifier and there is no planned return of the ICC ODI Super League.

There is no imminent sign of expansion of the Men's T20 World Cup and teams that do take part in 2028 will have one less group game to play. In the women's game, the top ranked associate sides have seen Zimbabwe - ranked 14th and 16th respectively in the ODI and T20I rankings - favoured for addition to the Women's Championship ahead of superior associate sides, and there is no sign of women's World Cups being brought into line with the size of the men's tournaments no matter how much the ICC like to crow about "equal prize money". There's been no moves to make the ICC more democratic, to give associates more of a say in how the game is run or to implement a fairer funding model.

Looking outside the associate members for a moment, there has been no expansion of the World Test Championship and women's Test cricket continues to wither on the vine with an upcoming England Test in the West Indies recently being canned.

So just what benefits is Jay Shah bringing to the global game? How is he making cricket more global or more popular? These are all questions one would like to put to him, but he almost never does interviews and when it does it's with compliant media who just lob softballs. I haven't seen anyone ask him "You have the momentum of a runaway freight train, why are you so popular?" yet, but it's only a matter of time.

Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe Jay Shah is really in the weeds with associate members, always helping and advising them. Maybe they're genuinely happy. I'd love to hear from anyone involved with an associate member with details of why they're happy. Or maybe these homages to the dear leader are just paying fealty to their overlord. Does anyone actually dare criticise him on the record? I doubt it.